Make a Donation to the NBN

The NBN is run by volunteers, but the network has expenses. If you like what we do, consider making a contribution

James FlemingFixing the Sky: The Checkered History of Weather and Climate Control

Columbia University Press, 2010

by marshall poe on October 20, 2010

James Fleming

View on Amazon

In the summer of 2008 the Chinese were worried about rain. They were set to host the Summer Olympics that year, and they wanted clear skies. Surely clear skies, they must have thought, would show the world that China had arrived. So they outfitted a small army (50,000 men) with artillery pieces and rocket launchers (over 10,000 of them) and proceeded to make war on the heavens. The idea was to “seed” clouds with silver iodide before they got to Beijing and rained on the Chinese parade. Or maybe the idea was to frighten the rain gods. Who knows? In any case, none of it worked: the massive, loud, and surely expensive operation had, according to most experts, no measurable effect on the weather around the Chinese capital.

You might say you can’t blame them for trying. But according to James Rodger Fleming, you can. In his incisive new book Fixing the Sky: The Checkered History of Weather and Climate Control (Columbia UP, 2010), Fleming shows that although people have always dreamed of controlling the weather, and many have tried to do so, no one has ever succeeded. The reason is simple: the atmosphere of the Earth is not like your refrigerator or oven. It’s just too big and complex to be man-handled by any known or even realistically imagined technology. But, as Fleming demonstrates, there are always desperate people who refuse to accept this intuitive fact. So we are presented with a gallery of rain-making mountebanks, charlatans, and swindlers ever-ready to part rain-seeking fools and their rain-seeking money. In Fleming’s excellent telling, the story is entertaining though a bit sad. It’s sadder still that the weather-controlling con is still being run by seemingly well-intentioned people who claim they can “fix” global warming by means of some out-sized, outrageous, and out-of-this-world engineering scheme. Fleming, who both knows the science and has looked at the history, is more than dubious. The only way we can “fix” the sky is to leave it alone and hope for the best. It turns out, however, that leaving the sky alone is hard. It’s actually easier to attack it, proclaim victory, and continue as before. Just ask the Chinese.

Please become a fan of “New Books in History” on Facebook if you haven’t already.

{ 2 comments… read them below or add one }

Tim Szeliga October 20, 2010 at 6:31 pm

I worked with an older guy in the 80′s who had worked on a weather modification program in the southwest during the 70′s. He said it is difficult to make rain, but relatively easy to make snow. If there was a source
of moisture and the right temperatures, the clouds could be coaxed into dumping a higher yield than usual. I think this was through cloud seeding rather than ground-based snow machines, like at a ski resort.

Their plan was to build a series of retention dams on a mountain, then overload the upper elevations with snow
so as to fill a chain of man-made alpine lakes with snowmelt in the springtime. They wanted to make a literal “Snowbank”, controlling the outflow through the dams and slowly parcelling out water to extend the irrigation season.

As Ed told it, they were too successful, There were record spring floods that year in the area, unnatural and statistically significant floods. The air force threw some money at local farmers and quietly scrapped the project.
The Army Corp of Engineers and Bureau of Reclamation still use this high-elevation dam method, but presumably without the steroid-boost of weather mod.

As my source is anecdotal, I’d be interested in hearing Mr. Fleming’s comments, as he might have encountered this project in his research.

Tim Szeliga
“All droughts end with a flood.”

grow tent November 15, 2014 at 7:23 pm

What Kinds Of Vegetables Can I Grow In A Hydroponic Grow Closet.
Once done, get back to Craven, retrieve your lens and get back to camp.
If you are a commercial greenhouse owner, you understand the need for a steady supply of seedlings.

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: